Page 1 of 1

Just had an image denied, wrongly I believe

PostPosted: Fri Jun 09, 2017 2:25 am
by burcs
The gutter is 10px all around and only shadow and glow is allowed there, however the logo must still fill all the way out to the beginning of the gutter unless the shadow/glow supersedes 10px.

Image

With zero effects applied you can see the logo (font) is right on the gutter. Now I'm being told I have to put part of the logo (font) in the gutter, simply because the font has shading, which nearly all rounded fonts do (it's Verdana Bold if that matters). So my logo does fill all the way out to the beginning of the gutter, yet was denied for "1 px transparent pixels"

Image

Here it is with the shadows if you want to save it and give me a ruling. Thanks.

Re: Just had an image denied, wrongly I believe

PostPosted: Fri Jun 09, 2017 7:23 pm
by ArieS
You're right. It's not a shadow or a glow so it shouldn't be in the gutter. It's really only visible when opening it with PS/Gimp. I can see how whoever modded that thought it was too small using the tools we have in the pending queue. We just don't have time to open every single images in PS/Gimp.

Anyway, re-upload it and put "OK'ed per ArieS" in the Comments.

Re: Just had an image denied, wrongly I believe

PostPosted: Fri Jun 09, 2017 7:51 pm
by burcs
No problem. I figured it was something like that. I wasn't happy with the shadow anyway, I like to keep them a little tighter than that but left it at defaults. I'll fix it and re-upload, thanks.